How To Break In Birkenstocks Without The Pain!

I wish I’d known how to break in Birkenstocks before getting my first pair. Getting new Birkenstocks for the first time was an exciting moment for me as I’d heard how comfortable and how great they were for posture.

I suffer from chronic back pain, so my footwear must be comfortable. I spent ages trying on various colors and styles of Birks. I eventually settled on a pair of Arizona Birkibucks in mocha.

This post contains affiliate links, and The Organizer UK may earn commissions for purchases made through the links in this post. For more details, see here. Thank you so much for your support! 

I was so excited to unbox my first pair of Birkenstocks and couldn’t wait to put them on.

However, much to my horror, my brand new Birkenstocks hurt my feet right across the toe bar, and as if that wasn’t enough, I found the footbed hard and uncomfortable.

I felt defeated and disillusioned. I loosened the adjustable straps in a desperate attempt to make them more comfortable, but it just made my new sandals too loose, and they kept falling off my feet when I walked.

I was so disappointed that I put them in the back of the wardrobe with the rest of my least favorite shoes, and there they sat for two years.

After spending years breaking in Doc Martens, I wondered if I could do the same with my Birkenstocks, so I tried the same method, and it worked!

So in this post, I’m going to show you how to break in Birkenstocks fast, so you can drag yours out of hibernation and start wearing them!

What are Birkenstocks?


Birkenstocks originated in Germany in 1774. They are sandals that consist of either leather, nubuck, or non-leather uppers, with a unique contoured footbed made from latex and cork. The cork footbed reacts to the shape of your foot over time. Birkenstocks also have shock-absorbing soles.

Why break in Birkenstocks?


Why do I need to break in Birkenstocks? This is a question people ask me quite often, and the answer is: you need to give your Birkenstock soft footbed break-in time and allow them time to mould to your feet. At first, it will feel as if the soles are rigid and that they will never feel comfortable, but believe me, they will eventually mould to your feet and become the most comfortable shoes you’ve ever worn. Trust me, the discomfort you feel at first will be worth it!

How should Birkenstocks fit?


The contours of the Birkenstock soft footbed should correspond to your foot arch, and the toe bar should fit comfortably beneath your toes.

The straps should be snug but not too tight, and you should be able to wiggle one finger between the straps and your foot.

Your foot should not be too far forward, and there should be no gap between the back of the shoe and your heel.

You can find out more about how to fit your Birks in the Birkenstock fit guide here.

Are Birkenstocks comfortable?

Are Birkenstocks suitable for walking long distances? This is a question I get asked a lot, and the answer is yes. Once you have broken in the leather straps and the soft footbed on your Birkenstocks, they are the most comfortable shoes you can have on your feet.

I wear mine all day long during the summer months and find them the most comfortable sandals to walk any distance in. I travel in mine and also wear them around the house instead of slippers.

Podiatrist opinion on Birkenstocks


Are Birkenstocks bad for your feet? And are Birkenstocks good for flat feet? These are questions that get asked quite a lot in my Facebook group which you can join here!

Many podiatrists recommend Birkenstocks as they have a raised foot arch and a soft footbed, making them comfortable for people with or without flat feet.

Over time, the cork footbed will mould to the wearer’s feet, and the imprint of their foot will be on the footbed, the sandal will start to feel like an extension of the foot, and the wearer will hardly know they are wearing shoes at all.

Some podiatrists recommend Birkenstocks to help improve posture.

How long does it take to break in Birkenstocks?


Breaking in Birkenstocks is super simple and not time-consuming at all. If you follow the steps below, you should be able to have your Birkenstocks fully broken in within a week.

There is no shortcut to breaking in your new Birks, so be prepared to put in the work to reap the rewards in a week!

Remember if you’re planning on wearing your new Birks to a festival be sure to spend the time breaking them in before you go!

How long do Birkenstocks last?


Birkenstocks should last you many years as long as you look after them properly and use the Birkenstock the care set.

If you use this Birkenstock care set regularly, it will keep your Birks looking like new! The kit includes a cork sealer for your footbed, a cleaner and refresher, a water and stain repelled, and a handy applicator brush.

Almost every component of the footwear can be repaired or replaced, making them a fantastic investment and giving you years of wear, and they are worth every penny. A replacement footbed, for instance, can cost anywhere between £10 and £50, depending on your style.

Image courtesy of Birkenstock.com

How to break in Birkenstocks

Knowing how to break in Birkenstocks properly will prevent you from suffering from blisters or rubbing and make them much more comfortable.

  1. Get the correct size and fit.

    Make sure you buy the correct size and width for your feet. If you are in any doubt about fitting, ask the assistant to help you. They will undo all the straps and adjust them to the correct width.

    You can purchase your Birkenstocks in a wide or narrow fit to suit your feet. You can also use the size calculator here!

  2. Wear them indoors for a few days.

    Wear your new Birkenstocks indoors for a few days until you have broken them in, and wear them for a little bit at a time to give your feet a rest.

  3. Wear your Birks with a thick pair of socks.

    The first few times you wear your Birkenstocks, wear them with a thick pair of socks like these, made by Birkenstock, don’t worry about how you look. For now, you’re not going outside in them just yet!

  4. Day 1

    Wear your Birkenstocks with thick hiking socks like these for approximately 5 minutes if you feel any pain take them off immediately.
    Wander around the house in them as you would a pair of slippers.

    Try doing this a few times a day for 5 minutes.

    Please make sure you break your Birks in when you are active. There’s no point trying to break them in when you are sitting in front of the tv with your feet up!

    Be sure to bend, stretch and move about as much as you can while you’ve got the buffer of the thick socks to absorb any sore patches.

  5. Day 2

    Wear your Birks and socks for a little bit longer on the second day.

    Repeat the same steps as above but wear them for approx half an hour, roughly three times a day or more if you can.

    This will help to stretch out the leather and soften the footbed.

    Remember to give your feet a rest in between each wear.

  6. Day 3

    Try wearing your Birkenstocks for a few hours with a bit of rest in between.

    Your Birks should be starting to feel much more comfortable now.

    Remember to keep active. The more you move, the quicker you can get these bad boys broken in!

  7. Day 4

    Wear your Birks without socks for about 10 -15 minutes a day, three times a day.

    Look out for any areas that rub; if you get an area that rubs, you can either go back to using socks until it is better or cover the area with moleskin or a plaster.

    Often people find that the most uncomfortable place is the toe bar. If this is the case for you, revert to wearing socks until it feels more comfortable.

    However, steps 4-6 should have helped to soften the toe bed already.

  8. Day 5

    Try wearing your Birkenstocks for a few hours at a time until you feel that they are comfortable.

    If you feel any discomfort at this stage, take them off and give your feet a rest; it’s not worth causing yourself any blisters at this stage.

    You can always try again later on in the day.

    If they are still painful, revert to wearing the socks.

  9. Day 6

    You might want to go for a short walk outside to make sure your Birkenstock comfort is increasing.

    Once you can see your footprint in the footbed of your Birkenstocks, you should find that they are fully broken in.

    Gradually increase the time that you wear your Birks outside until you are fully confident that they are comfortable.

If you’re not already a subscriber to my list, I’ve created this amazing FREE STARTER PACK of printable loveliness! Included is:

  • Twelve educational activities for kids to keep them occupied while you organize.
  • A to-do list to help you prioritize your chores
  • A weekly meal planner and shopping list to help you organize your dinners for the week.
  • A weekly planner so you can organize your week ahead.
  • A list of 6 things to do every single morning to supercharge your morning!

What are you waiting for? Whether you’re at the start of your journey or just need a little boost, these FREE printables will make your week a little easier! Click here to subscribe to our weekly updates!

organizing bundle

Remember, everyone is different, there will be some people who can wear their Birks straight away, then there will be others who take weeks to break in theirs. Take your time and remember not to rush each stage of the breaking in process!

Where to get Birkenstocks.


Be careful of cheap imitations, when buying Birkenstocks for the first time, always go directly through the Birkenstock website or via a reputable, approved stockist.

What to do if your Birkenstock toe bar hurts


If you feel your toe bar is still uncomfortable, you should continue to wear your thick socks until the toe bar goes soft and is more comfortable underfoot.

Some people like to hit the toe bar with a hammer to help soften it, but you must take care not to damage the footbed of the sandal.

If you decide to use the hammer method, wrap the sandal in a tea towel first to give the footbed some protection.

Please also remember that the toe bar should be moulding to the sole of your foot. Hitting it with a hammer will not help this process and may even hinder the breaking-in process and the unique comfort you get from the footbed.

How to soften Birkenstock leather


Sometimes you might find that your Birkenstock leather straps need a little help to soften up. To help soften the leather, you should apply balsam to the straps or leather upper. I like to use Doc Martens Wonder Balsam to make the leather more pliable and buttery soft.

Apply a liberal amount of the balm to the leather upper and allow it to soak in overnight. Then in the morning remove the excess with a very soft dusting cloth.

You can read more about how to break in leather shoes with wonder balsam in this post.

How to break in Birkenstocks with water.


Some people prefer to soak their Birkenstocks in water, then put thick socks on and walk around for a few hours to allow the leather to stretch. This is not a method I would personally advise as it may cause unnecessary damage to your sandals.

  • How To Fall Asleep After Drinking Coffee Before Bedtime

     After drinking coffee all day, you may find you are overstimulated by the caffeine and need to find ways to settle both your mind and body to help you get a night of better quality sleep. In this post, I will share with you some expert tips that will show you how to fall asleep […]


  • How To Make A Simple Morning Basket

    How To Make A Simple Morning Basket

    As many of you know, I’m always on the lookout for ways to make life easier for myself; however, self-care is often something that I struggle to fit into my chaotic lifestyle. Looking after kids is chaotic, but when you throw a child with ADHD into the mix, it really does ramp it up a […]


  • How 10 Minutes Of Meditation A Day Could Save Your Marriage

    How 10 Minutes Of Meditation A Day Could Save Your Marriage

    You’ve had a terrible day at work, the kids are fighting upstairs, your freezer broke, and you need to get to swimming lessons in five minutes, sound familiar? Whether you are a single mom, working mom, new mum, mom of teenagers, or a fur baby mom, life can suck at times, and it’s easy to […]


  • 9 Of The Very Best Protection Crystals For Your Home

    9 Of The Very  Best Protection Crystals For Your Home

    Whether you believe in the power of crystals or not, what harm can it do to sprinkle a few around the home to give your house protection from negative energies? You don’t need to be an expert on crystal healing, just knowing a little bit about the best protection crystals is all you need to […]


  • How to deal with menopause tingling and numbness.

    How to deal with menopause tingling and numbness.

    So, you’ve read about all the common menopausal symptoms, like weight gain, mood swings, vaginal dryness, hair loss, night sweats, and probably have experienced most of them. Another strange and unexpected symptom creeps up on you out of nowhere, and bam, there’s another one to add to the never-ending list! Let’s talk about that bizarre little symptom […]


  • How To Have Perfect Telephone Etiquette For Every Occasion

    How To Have Perfect Telephone Etiquette For Every Occasion

    Everywhere you look these days, people are glued to their phones. From young kids to the elderly, it seems we all have the bug. Has telephone etiquette gone out the window, or can we still claw back some manners when we use our phones? With the ever-increasing demand for technology, it makes the opportunity to […]


  • How To Break In Birkenstocks Without The Pain!

    How To Break In Birkenstocks Without The Pain!

    I wish I’d known how to break in Birkenstocks before getting my first pair. Getting new Birkenstocks for the first time was an exciting moment for me as I’d heard how comfortable and how great they were for posture. I suffer from chronic back pain, so my footwear must be comfortable. I spent ages trying […]


  • How To Boost Your Energy In The Morning!

    How To Boost Your Energy In The Morning!

    We all have those super slouchy days where we just can’t get motivated to do anything at all. Working, looking after the kids and home can take it out of the best of us and we can find we often have zero energy in the morning. I was looking for something that would bring back […]


FAQ

Are Birkenstocks worth it?

I think Birkenstocks are worth every penny once you’ve broken them in.
You can use them for distance walking, on the beach, in the house, in the garden, for casual drinks you can wear them just about anywhere!
Almost every component of the footwear can be repaired or replaced, making them a fantastic investment for years to come.

Can you advise me what to wear with Birkenstocks?

Birkenstocks are not the prettiest of footwear and have been described as being so ugly that they are cool.
Knowing how to wear Birkenstocks sandals is simple. Pair them with just about anything in your wardrobe.
✔️ Shorts
✔️Dresses
✔️Skirts
✔️Jumpsuits
✔️Jeans

Can I get second-hand, used Birkenstocks to mould to my feet?

Breaking in used Birkenstocks is not something I would recommend. This is because the previous owner’s foot will have moulded to the footbed, and you will find it almost impossible to create a unique footprint of your own.

If you are looking for used Birkenstocks, go for ones that the previous owner has only worn once or twice before selling. This will allow you to be the first person to break them in.

Take advantage of the fact that someone else gave up before breaking in their Birks!

How easy is it to break in closed-toe Birkenstocks?

Knowing how to break in Birkenstock clogs is pretty simple.
Just follow the same steps as you would break in Birkenstock sandals as above, and you will soon find that the clogs become softer and more pliable the more you wear them.

How do you clean Birkenstock footbeds, and how do you stop Birkenstocks from stinking?

Use a damp cloth with a small amount of dish soap to clean the footbed.
If your Birks are really whiffy, create a thick paste of bicarbonate of soda and water and apply the paste to the footbed. Allow to sit for about 15 minutes, then wipe away.

Once your Birkenstocks are clean and smell fresh, you can keep them clean with the Birkenstock care set, get it here.

Now you’ve learned how to make Birkenstocks more comfortable, read how to break in Doc Martens in this post!